Hobie, the furniture restorer in Donna Tartt’s best-selling The Goldfinch: A Novel told young Theo that he had thought he would study history and become a professor at Notre Dame. That’s my road not traveled, said Hobie. Maybe by restoring things, he thought, I’m involved in history anyway.
The road not traveled. People of a Certain Age, how many such roads define the map of your life?
I recall a super-highway or two, a few freeways, more two-lane roads, endless dirt tracks not taken. Every choice I have made picked a path and left others unexplored.
In college, I had summer jobs with U.S. National Bank and Pacific Telephone. Each firm had programs designed to attract college graduates to join the ranks of management trainees. There were limited financial incentives for junior management, but as we all know, high-ranking officers of banks and communications firms have done well financially in the past forty years. Who knows? Maybe I would have been one of them.
Instead, I chose graduate school. When I was 14, my older sister predicted I would become a history professor (like Hobie). My dad, a minister, had, I think, hoped that I would follow in his footsteps. Either version of me required a graduate education. So, goodbye corporate titan me.
I was admitted to graduate school in Political Science at the University of Washington and the School of Theology at Claremont. The choice was really about the discipline in which I would be a professor: Political Science or Sacred Theology. I chose the former.
Did I mention there was a war going on then? Graduating from college, even though married, I was likely to be classified ready to travel, courtesy of the U.S. government. Instead, I applied for a couple of draft classifications other than 1-A and ultimately ended up flunking a physical for alternative service. That process offered a host of roads to take or not. Happily for me, the ones I took kept me out of the insanity of war.
When I finished my dissertation in 1973, I was offered the chance for a promotion in the administration at the University of California, Riverside and an Assistant Professor in Political Science position at California State University, Fullerton. I was mistakenly under the impression that the teaching job was a one-year replacement. I learned that I was turning down a tenure-track position when I called the department chair to decline the offer.
Not becoming a full-time college professor or a minister were a freeway-sized professional choice roads not taken.
Deciding whom to marry was a super highway choice and, of course, required another person to make a complementary choice. The 49 years we have been happily married suggest that choice has worked out well.
At one time, I thought that a parlor game, played with friends, in which each person described what his or her life might have been had a different road been chosen, might be a fun way to learn more about your friends. Hobie’s comment to Theo in The Goldfinch came with the hint of disappointment. I rejected my parlor game idea because of the danger of digging up deep disappointments buried under the years of making the journey on the road taken as rewarding and pleasant as possible.
There are roads not taken by others that you applaud openly. My mom could have pursued a career in radio in New York in the 1940s—she had the education and a growing body of experience—had she not left that option to marry my dad. Thanks, Mom.
There are roads you might like to have taken that were abruptly closed off to you. I wanted to attend the Air Force Academy for college and then fly planes. I found out that I was 25 days too young to enter after I finished high school at age 16 years, 10 months. I could not see myself waiting around for a year to start college. As history unfolded, being a military pilot in 1968 was a different proposition than it had been when I aspired to apply in 1963. I was in a different frame of mind, too.
And there are roads one dreams about taking that are completely irrational. It was only size, speed and talent that kept me from the goal of succeeding Mickey Mantle in center field for the New York Yankees. But in my mind…
I am among the fortunate who, at least at the conscious level, have no regrets about roads not taken. I admit to occasional curiosity. But, my life at this point, dotted as it has been by ups and downs, is simply result of the arc of my life, the facts that have resulted from thousands of choices made.
Thinking about the road not taken is ultimately an exercise in fantasy. Visiting Fantasyland can be fun, but most rides at the real Fantasyland go around in circles.
And you know? I teach classes at the university and pray periodically in public; little glimpses of my roads not taken.
Daniel E. White
April 18, 2016